πŸ›οΈ Senate Engagement β€” 22 September 2026

SENATE BRIEFING
SENATOR SHOEBRIDGE

Legal representation in Australia should not depend on your bank balance β€” and Advanced Intelligence systems entering our courts must be accountable, traceable and subject to human review.

Senator Shoebridge β€” Greens NSW
Meeting: 22 September 2026
Five Pillars of Reform
Three Targeted Asks
Why This Meeting

SAME PROBLEM. DIFFERENT ROOM.

Senator Shoebridge has publicly raised the alarm about Advanced Intelligence being deployed by powerful institutions against working people β€” Atlassian (500 jobs), CommBank (300 jobs), Adore Beauty (40 jobs) β€” with no consultation, no worker protection, and no regulation in place to stop them.

Fair Go Justice documents the exact same dynamic playing out in a different room: Australian courts are now issuing mandatory Advanced Intelligence governance rules to self-represented litigants β€” ordinary people with no legal aid, no training, and no funded support to comply.

The institution is different: a court, not a corporation. The mechanism is different: a Practice Direction, not a restructuring notice. The pattern is identical: Advanced Intelligence deployed by the more powerful party against the less powerful party, with no regulation, no consultation, and no protection built in.

Fair Go Justice is on Senator Shoebridge's side of this argument. We are not asking him to embrace Advanced Intelligence in courts. We are asking him to champion the same principle he has already stated publicly: accountability, regulation, and human oversight before deployment β€” not after the damage is done.

The Reform Framework

FIVE PILLARS. ONE MOVEMENT.

01

Free Access to Justice

Proving innocence shouldn't cost everything you own. Legal Medicare β€” swipe your card.

02

National Judicial Integrity Commission

Who watches the watchman? Every decision-maker answers to someone. Even the gavel.

03

Institutional Accountability

Stop protecting the institution. Start protecting the citizen. Change teams.

04

Advanced Intelligence-Assisted Justice

The tools exist. Built in the trenches. They just need to change sides.

05

Court Document Integrity

Maximum security at the door. Zero security for the documents that decide people's lives.

Three Targeted Asks

WHAT WE'RE ASKING FOR

01

Senate Inquiry: Body-Worn Video and Advanced Intelligence in Courts

Mechanism: Legal & Constitutional Affairs References Committee motion
  • Police warn every citizen they are recording β€” that creates a reasonable expectation of access.
  • Footage is tendered by prosecution when it helps; withheld under GIPA when it doesn't.
  • Internal reviews are routinely rubber-stamped β€” not independently tested.
  • FCFCOA Practice Direction (29 May 2026): Family Court β€” 79% of litigants unrepresented β€” faces mandatory Advanced Intelligence governance with no funded support.
  • VLRC (3 Feb 2026): Australia's first law reform inquiry into Advanced Intelligence in courts β€” 30 recommendations β€” Senate has no equivalent federal inquiry.
  • Charlotin database (2 Jul 2026): 1,668 global Advanced Intelligence hallucination cases; 975 involve self-represented litigants β€” more than lawyers (653).
  • No parliamentary body has yet examined Advanced Intelligence specifically in courts.
02

Champion a National Judicial Integrity Commission

Mechanism: Parliamentary Joint Committee on the NACC; letter to the Attorney-General
  • Australia is the only comparable common-law nation without an independent federal judicial oversight body.
  • ALRC recommended a federal judicial commission in 2022 (Recommendation 5, Report 138).
  • Law Council has advocated for one since 2006.
  • Western Australia is actively legislating the model (WA Judicial Commission Bill 2026).
  • NACC Act excludes judicial officers by design β€” Operation Myrtleford (March 2026) exposed the grey zone.
  • The reasoning tree stops at the gavel β€” and that has to change.
03

Legal Medicare β€” Support FGJ's Five-Pillar Framework

Mechanism: Public endorsement; network introductions; Senate committee referrals
  • 380,000 Australians turned away from community legal centres annually.
  • 1.4M+ Australians with legal need unable to access the system.
  • Self-represented litigant rate tripled from 4.4% to 12.8%.
  • NLAP expired 30 June 2025 β€” no replacement.
  • $18.2B annual cost of unmet legal need.
  • $4.9B NPV from Advanced Intelligence integration; 1,050+ new funded positions; 22,000 sector-wide by 2030.
  • $2.25–$7 return per $1 invested.
Opening Hooks

SIX WAYS TO OPEN THE MEETING

01 β€” SAME PROBLEM, DIFFERENT ROOM
β€œYou raised it about workers. We document it about court users. Advanced Intelligence deployed by a more powerful institution against someone with no resources and no protection β€” and zero regulation to stop it. The only difference is the room it happens in.”
02 β€” ROBODEBT PRECEDENT
β€œRobodebt settled for $548.5 million. Without binding Advanced Intelligence disclosure rules, the next one is already running.”
03 β€” THE AFFIDAVIT TRAP
β€œThe Family Court now applies mandatory Advanced Intelligence governance to 79% unrepresented litigants β€” without funded support. Its 29 May 2026 Practice Direction says affidavit content must be β€˜in the witness's own words.’ Legal Aid NSW is no longer accepting family law clients from 1 July 2026. The people who lost legal aid are told they cannot use the tool they have. That is a trap.”
04 β€” SELF-REPRESENTED LITIGANTS ARE THE MAJORITY
β€œThe Charlotin database documented 1,668 Advanced Intelligence hallucination cases in court proceedings globally. 975 involve self-represented litigants β€” more than lawyers. This is not a risk. It is already happening.”
05 β€” VLRC: OFFICIAL RECOGNITION
β€œIn February 2026 the Victorian Law Reform Commission published Australia's first law reform inquiry into Advanced Intelligence in courts. It recommends principles, guidelines, education and human oversight β€” not suppression. The Senate has not yet responded. Fair Go Justice's framework is that response.”
06 β€” BWV: USE IT OR LOSE IT
β€œEvery time a citizen is pulled over, police say: this interaction is being recorded. That warning creates a reasonable expectation. The footage exists. But when citizens request it to clear their name, it is withheld. That is not transparency. That is a filter.”
Agency Access Map

WHERE SHOEBRIDGE CAN MOVE

Tier 1 β€” Direct Engagement

AgencyPillarFGJ Ask
Attorney-General's DepartmentAll fiveConsultation on Legal Medicare; seat at NLAP renegotiation; National Judicial Integrity Commission pathway.
DISR (Advanced Intelligence Taskforce)Pillar 4Recognise Advanced Intelligence-Assisted Justice as a complement to the National Advanced Intelligence Plan.
Digital Transformation AgencyPillar 4Adopt FGJ's three-tier human-in-the-loop model as justice-sector standard.
OAICPillars 4 + 5Right to human review for Advanced Intelligence-assisted legal decisions; body-worn video access reform.
NACCPillar 2Clarify jurisdiction over judicial conduct; champion a federal judicial commission.
NSW Police / GIPAPillar 3 + BWVSenate inquiry into selective body-worn video use and GIPA refusal rates.
Federal Court of AustraliaPillars 4 + 5Extend GPN-Advanced Intelligence to mandatory disclosure and annual audit reporting.

Tier 2 β€” Shoebridge Can Facilitate

Referral BodyAsk
Australian Human Rights CommissionFormal position paper on Advanced Intelligence in justice and algorithmic discrimination (ICCPR Article 14).
Productivity CommissionNew Access to Justice review including Advanced Intelligence cost-benefit analysis β€” last done 2014.
Australian Law Reform CommissionAdvanced Intelligence evidence law reference; no active reference currently exists.
Legal Aid NSW + Legal Aid QueenslandPhase 1 pilot partnership β€” Advanced Intelligence-Assisted Document Review (12 months).
Community Legal Centres AustraliaDistribution to 200+ CLCs nationally; direct reach to 380,000+ unserved Australians.

Tier 3 β€” Endorsement Opens Doors

BodyWhat Endorsement Achieves
Law Council of AustraliaFormal endorsement of Legal Medicare and the five-pillar framework for Senate submission.
CSIRO / Data61Technical co-design partner for FGJ oversight architecture.
Victorian Law Reform CommissionAlready issued 30 recommendations β€” expand to include an unrepresented-litigant implementation plan.
This is an advocacy briefing β€” not a legal conference and not a case strategy session. Do not hand up case documents unless Senator Shoebridge specifically asks. Close with: β€œI'm not asking you to carry my case. I'm asking for your honest read: is this something that should be looked at? Because if the system tried as hard to help people as it does to block them, we would succeed.”

FIVE PILLARS. ONE MOVEMENT.

Join the MovementRead the Five Pillars